Perimenopause sleep problems, and the advice that keeps me awake
After years of broken sleep, I’m looking more closely at the remedies we’re told to buy. H sometimes sleeps even less than I do, which makes the conversation about exhaustion difficult.
It is really irritating being told to get eight hours of sleep when you’re a woman going through perimenopause. As though the thought hasn’t occurred to you, or you’ve stayed awake deliberately to reconsider every questionable decision since 1993.
When I first wrote about this at 45, Cyrus was still at nursery and 3am was the hour my brain chose to review his bag. I’d settle for six hours without throwing off the duvet or wondering why my legs had decided to audition for Riverdance. I’m 51 now, and this update brings that earlier experience together with what I’ve since tried and read.
I understand the advice about a consistent bedtime, but it’s difficult to feel relaxed when sleep itself starts to feel like another job I’m doing badly.
Why sleep can change before periods stop
Perimenopause is the transition before menopause, and symptoms can start while you still have periods. The NHS lists sleep difficulties and night sweats among the symptoms. Poor sleep can also leave you tired and irritable during the day.
When I was still having periods, it was tempting to put everything down to stress or too much on my plate. I didn’t know how much perimenopause could affect my sleep.
I’ve woken so hot that I wondered whether somebody had switched on the central heating. It reminds me of the sauna at David Lloyd, except I’m in pyjamas and I haven’t voluntarily entered the room. After a broken night, I can find myself reading the same email three times before I understand it.
Once I’m in bed, keeping my legs still can feel uncomfortable, and moving doesn’t always settle them. The NHS guidance on restless legs syndrome explains that symptoms can have other causes, including iron deficiency. That gives me a reason to speak to a GP about my legs instead of assuming hormones explain everything.
When H sleeps even less than I do
H tells me that I sleep better than he does, and the annoying thing is that he’s right. His sleep can be dreadful, and I know there are nights when he gets even less rest than I do. That makes it harder to explain why I’m still exhausted.
I don’t think he means to dismiss my experience, and I can see why he expects more hours to leave me feeling better. The difficulty is that I can sleep for longer and still wake feeling unwell after night sweats.
I’d like to explain how tired I feel without seeming to dismiss his exhaustion.
What helps me settle at night?
Over the years, I’ve tried earlier bedtimes and warm baths, as well as meditation apps and less caffeine. Chamomile and Pukka Night Time Berry Tea both appear in my kitchen cupboard. I enjoy an evening tea, although I can’t say it improves my sleep.
Exercise helps me feel better physically and mentally. I love Zumba and a demanding IGN1TE Strike class, although I sometimes lie awake afterwards and wonder whether a late workout suits me. I don’t know whether the late class is responsible.
Next Level, by Stacy T. Sims and Selene Yeager, made me think more carefully about recovery. Published in 2022, it explores exercise and nutrition through menopause. It prompted me to think about the rest I need after a demanding class, although it isn’t a treatment for insomnia.
What frustrates me is the suggestion that a woman who still sleeps badly must have neglected her routine. I can follow the advice and still be awake at 3am.
What an Iranian study can tell us about remedies
Life with H introduced me to Persian traditions around food and tea, and I became interested in the remedies families pass down. A glass of Persian tea is rarely far away in our household. I want to know what evidence there is for the remedies families recommend.
A 2022 survey of 288 postmenopausal women in southeastern Iran found that 65.3% used at least one complementary or alternative approach in the previous year. These included herbs and nutritional supplements, as well as prayer. Women with menopausal symptoms were more likely to report their use.
That survey records what women used, not whether it helped them. It also concerns women after menopause, so it can’t establish what works during perimenopause.
I considered valerian, although herbal products can interact with medicines and aren’t suitable for everyone. A cup of chamomile tea is also different from a concentrated preparation in a clinical trial. I wouldn’t replace prescribed treatment with something from the kitchen cupboard.
My experience with BetterYou Magnesium Max
Product disclosure. BetterYou Magnesium Max was not gifted. These comments describe my own experience.
I find BetterYou Magnesium Max Original helpful as part of my evening routine. It’s unflavoured and easy to mix, so I don’t need several tablets or a complicated ritual. I can’t isolate the effect of magnesium from the rest of my evening routine, so I don’t claim it treats insomnia or restless legs.
The manufacturer’s current product details list magnesium glycinate, citrate and malate, with 375mg of elemental magnesium in a 2g serving. Its directions say to mix half a teaspoon (2g) into 250ml of water. Those are product instructions, not a personal dose recommendation from me.
A 2021 review of three trials involving 151 older adults found possible benefits for the time it took to fall asleep, but the evidence was low or very low quality. It doesn’t establish that this product improves sleep during perimenopause.
The NHS advice on magnesium says high doses above 400mg can cause diarrhoea in the short term, and evidence about long-term high doses is insufficient. That figure isn’t a recommended dose or a guarantee that a supplement suits everyone. Count magnesium from other supplements too, and ask a pharmacist about medicines or health conditions before adding it.
Magnesium in bath water is a separate question from magnesium taken by mouth. My six-week Westlab bath salts review looks at that experience without treating a relaxing bath as proof of a medical benefit.
I still want to investigate products that make nights more comfortable, including cooling bedding and mattress toppers. I’ll describe any difference I notice in future Saffron Experiment reviews and disclose gifts or commercial arrangements.
Health note. This is personal experience and a discussion of research, not individual medical advice. Supplements and herbal products can interact with medicines and don’t replace prescribed treatment.
More from Saffron & Cyrus
What I noticed after a soak, and the limits of claims about magnesium through the skin.
A separate look at menopause research and why an association doesn’t prove prevention.
What I tried when poor sleep made a full workout feel difficult.
Discover more from Saffron & Cyrus
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
