Are we worrying about our children’s screen time for all the wrong reasons?
Between Minecraft negotiations and my own phone habits, I’m questioning how we judge children’s screen time, and why counting minutes tells us so little about what they’re doing.
The five-minute Minecraft negotiation
There is a silence in our house that usually means Cyrus is gaming. I can call his name three times, raise my voice on the fourth and eventually discover that something terribly important is happening on his screen. Yet the moment I announce that his time is up, my previously unresponsive child develops excellent hearing. Another five minutes is essential to whatever he’s doing.
H and I use parental controls and restrict gaming, which sounds terribly organised until we’re negotiating with a child who insists that switching off now would be catastrophic. We want technology to leave room for the rest of his childhood, but I’m questioning how much we learn from counting the minutes.
Parents and children see the same screen differently
The Internet Matters 2024 digital wellbeing report illustrates that divide. Among the parents surveyed, 63% believed time online negatively affected their children’s health. Meanwhile, 75% of children saw technology and the internet as important to their independence. These are reported views, and the survey doesn’t establish that screens caused a particular health problem.
It doesn’t follow that children are better judges of every risk, or that parental concern is misplaced. They can enjoy being online and encounter harm there. It does suggest that a conversation about what a child enjoys can tell us something that a screen-time report can’t.
My phone is rarely far away either
Growing up, I remember the ZX Spectrum, its clunky loading noises and games that tested your patience before they’d even started. Nobody seemed interested in measuring our exposure by the minute. Today, parents have monitoring software and enough conflicting advice to make any decision feel like a safeguarding exercise.
Concern about children’s screens is hardly new. In the 2022 NortonLifeLock survey, 89% of UK adult respondents agreed that most children were addicted to screens, while 88% thought parents relied too heavily on screens to keep children busy. Those figures measure adults’ perceptions, not clinical diagnoses.
I recognise the convenience. Sometimes there’s dinner to prepare or work to finish, and I appreciate the peace when Cyrus is happily gaming. Between work, messages, banking and whatever I’ve suddenly decided needs Googling, my own phone is rarely far away. H is much the same. Adults get to decide what counts as important screen use, which is a useful arrangement for adults.
I wrote about the screen-time rules lockdown broke when our own laptops made those rules difficult to defend. The pressure to keep up doesn’t disappear with age either, as I found with the school WhatsApp group and its extra parenting job.
Gaming needs its own questions
Playing a game with friends can involve cooperation and problem-solving, but gaming and social media aren’t neatly separate worlds. Games can include chat and contact with strangers, so knowing the game’s name isn’t enough. I want to know who Cyrus communicates with and what happens when something upsets him.
Having grown up before social media, I’m conscious of how easily children can compare themselves with others. School friendships were complicated enough without seeing who’d been invited somewhere and whether you’d been left out. I want Cyrus to understand privacy settings and age restrictions, and to feel comfortable telling us about an upsetting experience without assuming he’ll immediately lose his favourite game.
Why we still have gaming limits
Expecting Cyrus to announce that he’s enjoyed precisely enough gaming for one day would be an exceptionally optimistic parenting strategy. A routine leaves time for schoolwork and swimming, and parental controls save H and me from constantly intervening. Technology has yet to invent a setting that eliminates the words “It’s not fair.”
The NSPCC’s guidance on compulsive device use explains that long periods of scrolling or gaming, especially late at night, can disrupt sleep and wellbeing. It also advises seeking support when technology use causes distress or affects schoolwork and relationships.
As someone who loves the gym, I want Cyrus to enjoy being active, but I don’t want exercise to become a punishment for playing games. On a wet Newcastle afternoon, gaming is a perfectly OK way to spend some time. I pay more attention to whether he’s sleeping properly and still interested in life beyond the screen.
I’ve never worried about Cyrus’s relationship with swimming because he doesn’t want to get out of the pool. A complaint when gaming ends doesn’t tell me enough on its own either, although problems elsewhere in his life would give me a reason to reconsider our approach.
Cyrus is growing up in a digital world that looks very different from the one I knew. Eventually, he’ll make his own decisions about who he speaks to and when he’s spent enough time online. I want our boundaries to help him develop that judgement. For now, I still want him swimming, playing tennis and enduring a family outing without asking when we’re going home, while accepting that gaming is something he enjoys.
More from Saffron & Cyrus
How working from home complicated our rules about Cyrus’s iPad.
The digital demands that follow parents beyond the school gate.
What happened when we introduced Cyrus to games H and I remembered from childhood.
Discover more from Saffron & Cyrus
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
