Are we overcomplicating Halloween?
Halloween is supposed to be about imagination and fun. So why has it started to feel like another thing parents have to buy, organise and get right?
Having trawled the supermarkets looking for a Halloween costume for Cyrus, I can report with some horror that dressing a child now seems to cost the GDP of a small country. Trying to find anything under £10 felt like searching for gold.
Of course, he’ll probably wear it once, then it will end up in the back of a cupboard or on Vinted. Looking at the £10, £12 and £15 options, I wondered whether Halloween had become another occasion where parents are expected to spend, plan and perform. I’ve also written about the competing demands on our family budget, including Cyrus’s request for a £30 Halloween costume.
I don’t remember it feeling like that when I was little, although my dad might have disagreed. He was the one who had to carve the turnip.
We had a turnip for a lantern
We didn’t have rows of ready-made costumes or a choice of 20 different versions of the same pumpkin. We just had our sturdy turnip, and I can still remember my dad having to carve the bloody thing.
He had to hack away at the inside of this stubborn root vegetable to create enough room for a candle, while trying not to take his fingers off. Then came the holes in either side and the string, so I could carry it around.
Which meant that I, as a small child, was wandering around outside with a live flame inside a hollowed-out vegetable dangling from my hand. The smell was a pungent combination of singed turnip and something resembling a bonfire in a kitchen bin.
That part can stay in the past. NI Direct’s Halloween safety advice recommends a torch, glow stick or battery-operated candle inside pumpkins and turnips.

I also remember the Halloween competitions at primary school, because there was always one parent who took it very seriously. One year, a mum wrapped her son in crepe bandages and covered him in wet flour and water to make him look like a mummy.
He looked terrifying and won the best-dressed competition, although I suspect his mum deserved the prize as much as he did. My own costume was a Scottish Highlander, of course, and to this day I have no idea why.
My mum dressed me in a tartan sash, and looking back, I think she may have given up on the Halloween theme. While one child was covered in homemade gloop, I was representing the Highlands. I was delighted with my tartan kit and don’t remember asking for something from a shop.
Maybe the problem isn’t the costume
I’m not convinced everything was better when we were children. My dad wrestling with a turnip and another parent turning her child into a convincing corpse hardly suggest that Halloween used to be effortless.
I’m not against buying costumes either. If Cyrus desperately wants to be something specific and it makes him happy, then that’s what we’ll do. Most of us are just trying to get through modern parenting without adding another job to the list.
When Halloween arrives with decorations, themed food and enough sweets to keep a small village awake until Christmas, buying something ready-made can feel like the easiest option. The pressure comes when every part of the occasion needs to look impressive.
Five easy Halloween costume ideas
I came across Playdale’s five-minute World Book Day costume guide. Several ideas could work for Halloween too, depending on what your child wants to wear. Five minutes is the guide’s promise, and I haven’t timed these myself. Finding the right top could take longer than putting the costume together.
These options start with clothes you may already own. Miss Trunchbull, the witch and Wally also feature in Playdale’s guide, and Minecraft Steve and Wednesday Addams offer two more options.
1. Miss Trunchbull
Black trousers, a grey sweatshirt, a big belt and slicked-back hair. Add a pretend chocolate cake if you have one, although the outfit works without it.
2. The Room on the Broom witch
A red top, purple or black skirt, a plait and a bow. A cuddly cat can join in, and an existing witch’s hat helps if there’s one in the cupboard.
3. Steve from Minecraft
Blue jeans, a turquoise T-shirt and brown shoes. A cardboard pickaxe is an optional extra if you have time to make one.
4. Where’s Wally?
Blue jeans, a red-and-white striped top, glasses and a bobble hat. Then send your child into the Halloween party and try to find your own child.
5. Wednesday Addams
A black dress, white collar, two plaits and your child’s best deadpan expression. Sometimes the attitude does most of the work.
Homemade doesn’t automatically mean safer
The London Fire Brigade’s costume guidance warns that homemade outfits can catch fire too. Keep costumes away from flames and use battery-operated lights. Avoid trailing fabric, check that children can see clearly and move easily, and add reflective details if they’re out after dark.
Keep the costume, lose the pressure
Look at what you already have before buying anything, and reuse old costumes if they still fit. I don’t want to recreate a professional costume department at the kitchen table, any more than I want to spend a fortune on something Cyrus wears once.
What stays with me from childhood is the turnip, the mummy boy and my tartan sash. None of that depended on a perfect costume, although it did involve parental effort that I probably appreciated less at the time.
I’m happy to leave the live candle behind. The delight of becoming a Scottish Highlander for reasons nobody in my family can now explain is worth keeping.
What’s the homemade Halloween costume you still remember, and was it the one you wanted to wear?
More from Saffron & Cyrus
The Halloween when a Persian fruit bowl caused a fright
A different set of expectations meets British trick-or-treating.
Occasional stories, experiments, discoveries and questions from Saffron & Cyrus.
Discover more from Saffron & Cyrus
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
