The handsome stranger had an unfair advantage when I first watched Shirley Valentine, the 1989 film starring Pauline Collins. I was a teenager and Greece looked like an excellent place to fall in love. I paid less attention to the married woman wondering what had happened to her own life. At 51, she is the person I want to understand.
Pauline Collins became a heroine of mine, although I understood very little about Shirley’s frustration. Now I’m married and raising a son, with perimenopause part of my own experience. I understand more about having a life you have built over years, and still wanting a say in what happens next.
I thought Greece was the answer
My teenage imagination had plenty to work with. I went to Greece with my parents and remember sunburnt afternoons on pebbled beaches in Rhodes, plates of feta and olives, and the smell of salt and citrus. Back home, I lived in a small village where everyone knew everyone else’s business before you did. Greece offered the possibility of being somewhere nobody knew mine.
I thought other cultures were more exciting than my own, a conclusion reached on holiday with very little knowledge of anyone else’s daily life. It is easy to romanticise a country when you have no responsibility for paying its electricity bills.
Years later, on a night out in Whitley Bay, I met H. My tall, dark, handsome Greek stranger turned out to be a short, dark, handsome Persian prince. He whispered that he was Persian, although I had already decided he was Greek. That misunderstanding is still a running joke between us more than 20 years later.
We love Greece together, and our family holiday in Corfu belongs to a life I could hardly have imagined as a teenager. My story took its own route, with a lot more Persian food.
Can I relate to Shirley at 51?
I can relate to her wish to make her own decisions. That is different from saying we have the same marriage, or that I want to leave mine. Shirley is a character with her own disappointments. I have H and our son, and the life we have made together.
What I understand now is the weight of the decision. As a teenager, I could imagine going abroad and starting again without thinking much about the people at home. At 51, I know that a change in one person’s life can affect the whole family. It is harder to picture a different future when you know what you would have to rearrange.
My writing and fitness are part of that question for me. I choose them because I want them in my life. Being a wife and mum does not remove those interests, although it does mean they sit alongside commitments I take seriously. I can care about my family and still want time for something of my own.
The BFI includes Shirley Valentine in its selection of films about making a fresh start. Its account also draws attention to Shirley finding comfort in being alone. That is a part my teenage self gave little thought to. I was too interested in who she might meet.
There is more to her than the holiday
Collins gives Shirley warmth and wit, and now I notice how much of her frustration that humour carries. She wants a change before she has worked out what the change will mean. I understand that uncertainty more than I did when the Greek holiday seemed to explain everything.
For me, the question at 51 is what I want to keep making room for within the life I have. Writing belongs there, and so does fitness. I do not need to know where every decision will lead before I take those interests seriously.
My teenage self wanted Shirley’s adventure. Now I understand more about why she chooses to go. My own handsome stranger came via Whitley Bay, and we have had more than 20 years of life together since then. There is still room for me to decide what I want from the years ahead.
And if H wants steak and chips, or egg and chips, he knows where the cooker is. My affection for Shirley has survived into midlife, along with a few useful principles.
If you first watched Shirley Valentine when you were young, do you recognise more of yourself in her now?
More from Saffron & Cyrus
At 50, I finally understand the film ‘Labyrinth’
Another film I loved when I was young, and what I see in it now.
The British-Persian family and experiences behind the publication.
Come along for the ride.
Occasional stories, experiments, discoveries and questions from Saffron & Cyrus.
Discover more from Saffron & Cyrus
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Lovely post